Silpoly vs silnylon reddit Based on that. I know that many companies sell silpoly raincoats. 9 silpoly is really prone to failure in shelters. MLD comes with a sil bag already. What would be the best material for the tarp? I heard that silnylon and sil-poly are great materials, but what is really the difference? Jan 29, 2016 路 If it were half the cost of SilNylon, I *might* do more with it simply because it is lighter. 2). Silnylon can be patched with seam seal easily. Holding up great. Also, silpoly packs down smaller than dcf, but is roughly 3 oz heavier at that size. But I’ve spent many grueling hours looking for the right silpoly for a tent, from all conceivable sources, including tent makers and fabric dealers in Europe and Asia, all to no avail; so thought an inquiry here might get me off the dime where I’m stuck. 6 HyperD PU4000 is good bathtub material. Like silnylon is more prone to needing readjustment after setting up/getting wet. I can get SilNylon for $4. May 18, 2021 路 As for the demerits of silpoly vs silnylon bonding, I’d need to see someone post some evidence of that. Right now I am realy leaning towards the minifly but ny only worry is the 30D fabric would be flimsy. For on trail it might work well. WE had more misting issues with 20D silpoly and the real stretch/sag issue with silnylon was not so significant, which is why we went back to silnylon for our tents. Actually, that's four out of five, but I'll let Meat Loaf do the selling on purchasing a SilPoly Superfly: Meatloaf to GingeGirl about SilPoly(cue the music, please) "Baby we can talk all night I own the older silnylon beta light, and recently received the new silpoly version. Plenty of silnylons, especially the thinner ones, are just as if not more slippery. silnylon stretches and sags, silpoly does not. Strong ripstop nylon with silicone-based adhesive, these patches are perfect for repairing silnylon tents, tarps, backpacks and stuffsacks. Dyneema (DCF) Dyneema Composite Fabric (DCF), formerly known as Cuben Fiber, is another popular option for lightweight outdoor gear. 9 or so, and most is around 1. Silpoly packs smaller than Cuben, stretches less than silnylon and is strong enough for all I've been able to throw at it. I really like how tiny it packs down. In the case of UltraTNT, that looks like two polyester films sandwiching a grid of Ultra (or ultra-high-molecular-weight polyethylene) fibers. This would mean that silpoly is a bit more waterproof (I. But silnylon is also stronger, so it’s a trade off. Another option is silnylon. Both garments perform as advertised, with the AGG having a beefier silnylon material and offering a closer fit (6’0 170#), but the Packa vents a bit better. I put an added silpoly layer (top of forearm and cuff area) to the wind shirt sleeves for rain. Which one is more waterproof? It is… Posted by u/goingforalittlewalk - 5 votes and 7 comments To keep the weight of silpoly the same as silnylon, you have to drop from a 30D nylon to a 20 D poly, and, the silpoly has a MUCH lower tear strength than silnylon. Nothing for a tent. 馃 I’d probably go woven/silnylon floor, but I also haven’t gone pro yet due to not being able to justify coughing up the $ for DCF. Silnylon vs. Silnylon has gotten wayyy better in the time that DCF has been on the scene, and quality Silpoly is both available and widely used enough to understand its durability. The generous pit zips help with venting when I’m using it in warmer temps (only tested to a little over 15*C), it works really well as a wind block for me, and I can zip everything up to generate some heat if needed. Oct 14, 2014 路 As it's been said, Sil-Nylon is impregnated with silicone. The stretch is only noticeable long term in tarps too. I backpack mainly in the East TN mountains. I'm having a surprisingly difficult time actually finding good hydrostatic head measurements of either. 1 Oz/sqyd Silpoly because my only complaint with my Zpacks poncho is that it doesn't pack down very well, it's kind of loud to wear (because it's 1 Oz/sqyd DCF), its expensive AF, and no one makes the same design anymore. does a silnylon/silpoly puffer even exist right now? I'm very interested in this topic, as Volleback makes a UHMWPE(pure dyneema thread) puffer but with polyester fill; I'd be interested in trying to get a big company on Alibaba to custom fabricate some 7-10 denier UHWMPE woven silkweight fabric and hire someone to put together stuff. Sewing Sil-Nylon is a test of patience. Silnylon absorbs moisture which causes the material to relax, so it looses tautness after setup. Nov 3, 2023 路 2. I got a very light silpoly for a tarp that I use with hammocking and as a ground family tarp, because I'm never, ever going to test it in a very windy situation. 7 ounces for the kilt, umbrella, and tunic vs 10. xenon sil is just a 20d silpoly. Compare weight, durability, breathability, cost, and more to determine the ideal fabric for your thru-hiking needs. My silnylon tent always feels waterlogged when I pack it out, but my silpoly tarp doesn't hold much water after a quick shakeout. That said: Borah makes some incredible tarps, and the owner (Jim?) is an incredibly kind and responsive guy. For the difference in weight, I'd just got with the 1. Abrasion/puncture resistance- DCF is more prone to punctures than silpoly/silnylon. It is known as a plain weave fabric. I went back and forth on silpoly vs dcf vs silnylon. Funny you ask about MYOG! I'm in the middle of making a MYOG poncho groundsheet from PU4,000 1. I'm in the southwest, and much of the ground is volcanic based with lots of little rocks, I've cleared out the big ones and most of the small ones when I can, but I know I'm My question is regarding silnylon vs silpoly; im curious how much better is the silpoly is it worth the upgrade? Does the sag on impregnated sil nylon really impact the performance? My YE bonus is coming in and im hoping to purchase myself an upgrade for this up coming season, I can afford either one however im not sure whats a gimic and whats Lots of discussion on silpoly vs silnylon, but basically silpoly is more UV resistant and won't sag when wet. DCF is definitely sticky, i've noticed that too. 77 oz Silnylon, greater tensile strength and less stretch while still being cheaper than DCF. My recommendation would be a rectangular tarp, 9 feet long and 6 or 7 feet wide. If you use shelters like most backpackers do - set up in early evening when you make camp for the day and take down in the morning when you start hiking again, UV damage is a non-issue. silpoly: So, what's the big difference anyway? Silpoly has become tremendously popular mainly because it stays taut under load. 5 osy finished) 30D MTN Silnylon 6. SilPoly is "lighter, tighter, can handle an all-nighter" (when raining) - as well as UV resistant. Read this how you want, however, my personal feeling is that the silpoly they sold me is actually silnylon. No sag at all on the silpoly version after 2 soaking nights. 75oz Membrane 10 Ripstop Nylon for the top torso section. 6 oz silpoly. Overall, the best all purpose materials (in my opinion) are either plain 1. Dec 2, 2022 路 But am considering silpoly for the next floor in order to keep the fabric flat and stable. Ultimately I was okay with being slightly heavier than dcf to save pack volume. 1 silnylon or 1. I’ve been really happy with my silpoly tarps, and I’m not super gentle with my gear. I will use for comparison our Silnylon , and the MTN Sil from Ripstop since it has a similar coating as ours and SilPoly from Ripstop. 4oz. Why do you want to carry a tent footprint? I have worn silnylon rain chaps for hundreds of miles. If it doesn't already exist I wager that SMD will have a SilPoly Gatewood at some point as they appear to be making SilPoly versions of their other shelters More durable (20D vs 10D), better material for worse conditions (silpoly vs silnylon, which will sag and absorb water when wet), two huuuuuge vestibules, easier setup, less stakes required, more storm/wind proof tent geometry, and most importantly (to me), it’s DOUBLE WALL so the condensation issues aren’t nearly as bad. I've made a silnylon net tent with a silnylon tarp and now I'm looking for a groundsheet. Only thru hikers rival my outdoor time. Particularly useful in outdoor applications to minimize sag/stretch when wet and color fade over time. The materials are identical in every way. g. It's very robust. 1oz 20D recycled ripstop SilPoly for the bottom and a 0. Probably 8 oz vs 5 oz silpoly vs 0. Bulk- DCF doesn't pack down as small as silpoly/silnylon. 1 silpoly, what are the pros and cons of one over the other? 10-28-2018, 19:48 #2 Just sewed up a 9x9 silpoly tarp and from my initial setups, i gotta say that the bit of stretch in silpoly makes it pitch much nicer than silnylon with a bit of fudge room on the guyline geometry. Apr 26, 2024 路 On the other hand silnylon/silpoly can hold a lot of water and of course that means a far heavier shelter to carry around, at least until you get a chance to maybe stop and let it dry out. Posted by u/Ernie_McCrackenX - 5 votes and 9 comments Jul 1, 2022 路 There are both Polyester and Nylon silicone coated fabrics (Silnylon, Silpoly). 8 DCF holds up considerably better and longer than . The main two I see discussed are polycro and tyvek, I just can't decide on which. the fabric feels robust enough to stand up to frequent use, but the PU backer feels kind of clingy. Feb 19, 2023 路 For most brands, the differences between silpoly and silnylon are negligible; most use 20-denier or 30-denier fabrics that are about 1. Roughtly 6oz for DCF vs 10-11oz for Silpoly of the same size as a percentage it seems like a big difference but either one is going to take a respectable chunk out of your BPW vs a tent. I've used an X-Mid Pro 2 for more than a year. But would be curious to hear others’ thought process. If the colors and shades are exactly the same, then polyester does edge out nylon some. Regarding durability, the Warbonnet is 20D silnylon, which will be more durable than the LHG 20D silpoly (LHG does also have a 30D silnylon option), but less durable than the AGG 70D silnylon. The reason I like having Silnylon on the Nimbus is just the durability factor- it even feels more durable, the X mid feels fragile, like I need to baby it. 1 oz vs $100 on the 2p. As mentioned above silpoly absorbes less water, drys faster, and doesn't sag when wet, it's also a bit lighter than silnylon. The darker the fabric, the better it resists UV damage. I will be buying a kit over the winter and am on the fence between these two. 1 ounces per square yard. Regarding packability, most of the time a pure Silicone coated fabric will be better at packing. Mar 6, 2022 路 In my opinion, sliders tend to wear out much more quickly on DCF tents than on silnylon or silpoly tents because DCF tents are high tension and therefore put a ton of stress on the zipper. Maybe I'll just wait for a few months to see if anything comes out in the meantime. They’re also very hard to get a perfect pitch with if you’re spatially challenged 馃ズ and they are so bulky. Apr 17, 2023 路 Silpoly and Silnylon are two types of fabrics used for outdoor gear. So on balance, I suspect that Jon is right and silpoly is the greener fabric. I don’t have really expensive gear, but I do have an EE quilt and a DCF 7x9 tarp. Even though my silnylon chaps and rain skirt aren’t waterproof anymore they still sort of work. Not quite what you wanted to hear, but I use a standard RAB Poncho tarp in sil nylon, and made my windshirt. Probably the reverse. It's very slippery when placed against itself. The main differences are square vs rectangle, Xenon Sil vs Silnylon, and tie outs along along the center seam for the REI tarp. Silpoly and silnylon both are more slippery then dcf which helps with shedding snow, and have a bit of stretch, silnylon more so than silpoly, which can make it easier to get a good pitch. I'm guessing there's a reason this hasn't been done. "As you may have guessed from their names, silpoly is made from silicone-coated polyester while silnylon is made from silicone coated nylon I haven’t used the 1. May 6, 2014 路 Quite an interesting topic. Hello hammock campers if reddit, I'm looking to buy a tarp for my ENO double nest hammock and right now I'm deliberating between the warbonnet outdoors minifly (30D silnylon) and the ENO profly. Actually, that's four out of five, but I'll let Meat Loaf do the selling on purchasing a SilPoly Superfly: Silnylon vs. The stretch factor of silnylon actually helps it in windy conditions compared to a taut pitch. I’m all silpoly or dyneema now. 1 oz silnylon or 1. I’m happy with silpoly for a 3 season shelter. it's also more fragile, so while holding up into the wind is mostly dependent on how you orient it towards the wind and how it's tie-outs and stakes are set, another consideration is things falling from the wind (like sticks, pine cones, etc) can be a threat to punch through the material. It seemed surprising to me though since the 1. (Snow sticks much more on DCF from experience vs SilPoly will have it slide off easier. But , depending, I do more camping in a year than most. I'm surprised more manufacturers haven't started using Silpoly. You'll have the poncho design to help you breathe. r/Ultralight is the largest online Ultralight Backcountry Backpacking community! This sub is about overnight backcountry backpacking, with a focus on moving efficiently, packing light, generally aiming at a sub 10 pound base weight, and following LNT principles. Like, I'd trust a 20d silnylon that Ron tested and selected against, e. For the record, they (silnylon, silpoly, dcf, etc) are all degraded by UV and mechanical stress. Whereas the heaviest silnylon is 1. I'm guessing this is a mixture of silicone and PU which kind of blew my mind. Light Heart Gear sells the suit that I own. I think the 3F is really nice as a small tarp and then as a bonus can be worn as a poncho. The Silpoly has a Velcro closure for the vestibule and no magnets for holding up the rolled vestibule. Never had an issue with the quest for durability, and I don't have any reason to think the thunderfly will be any different in that regard. This also allows the manufactures to upgrade certain aspects on their tents that are not found on UL free standing tents. 3oz SilNylon, 0. I'm looking for some guidance on material selection. I got rid of mine for a silpoly lunar solo. IMO the difference in UV resistance between silnylon and silpoly is vastly overstated (usually by people selling silpoly shelters). A ce que j'ai compris, le silnylon a une moins bonne résistances aux UV et à également l'avantage de moins s'affaisser sous la pluie et le vent. We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. - Dual vents (vs no vents) - Full coverage fly to block rainsplatter/drafts (vs higher cut fly) - Double wall (vs singlewall) And for space the X-Mid is quite a bit more generous with 92" x 50" floor (vs 81" x 48/42"), more headroom from a longer ridgelilne, and much larger vestibules. The silpoly versions are less expensive (as cheap as $100 for the Mongar 2p), have way better water resistance and won't sag in the rain and have better uv resistance. I'd personally lean against a bivy, and get a bug net inner. See full list on trailandsummit. 51. Silnylon starts off a bit stronger in tear strength and you can get it in a 30D for high stress use-however it will sag when wet and takes longer to dry out. SilNylon is stronger (but by how much I do not know). However, this gear isn’t ultra-light, thus enter SilNylon. Built a RSBTR silpoly 5. 1 oz (1. com SilPoly is "lighter, tighter, can handle an all-nighter" (when raining) - as well as UV resistant. I keep seeing claims of 'our silnylon is superior', but I have yet to find a sample that really is superior. I think if there was a silpoly version (single wall, sub 30oz), I would be all over that. I'm totally on board with silpoly as a material, and all of my tarps are silpoly. You dont need the benefits of silnylon imo: stretch and durability. The REI tarp will be a little cheaper after a 20% off coupon. Less prone to misting), but others may correct me. Jan 2, 2021 路 With the advent of improved polyester tent fabrics and coatings, a superlight silpoly tent should be within reach for MYOG. It is quite strange that you only save 3oz going with DCF. 1 oz silpoly, personally. I'll bring my 10 x 10 Cuben tarp when sharing a shelter with a pal. PU4000 would be $7. It sounds like durability is one of your main questions. AGG rain jacket and Packa owner here. I wouldn’t do a silnylon, from what I’ve heard the time they take to dry out even from (frequent) condensation is ugh. 2. silnylon vs. They are great fabrics and I'd put them up against any comparable nylon fabric in a strength test. I strongly prefer silpoly in general, but could see the argument for silnylon on, say, a duomid used for 4 seasons. Jul 22, 2024 路 We use a nano-ripstop silpoly fabric with a 3000mm sil/sil coating on it for most of our tents, and our 8P uses a 30D nano ripstop silpoly fabric. Like you I became fed up with the limited benefits of WPB rainwear. This fabric is coated with a silicone/PU layer on each side and is waterproof/non-breathable. I haven't had any issues yet, but just looking at how often other people get tears in Silpoly vs Silnylon it's enough to give me pause. ) My friends dog flung himself a few times this year onto my 2020 DCF Cirriform Min (with both trekking poles for support placed inside while I was sleeping and with 2 Ruta Locura stakes at the head and foot ends. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. The cost savings from using the sil-nylon floor went into hot bonding the DCF upper tent which is much stronger and more waterproof than using tape which is used on most other DCF tents. Both materials have excellent durability and strength, making them popular choices for camping tents, backpacks Feb 6, 2021 路 Obviously, if one or the other fabric needs replaced more often, that might more than offset any differences in production. I'm leaning towards using silpoly with a PU4000 coating because it sounds like PU coatings have better UV resistance. Silpoly is pretty much the same thing as silnylon — just trade out the nylon yarn for polyester. Dcf has no stretch, and sometimes you'll see points on a dcf shelter where tension or wind has caused it to permanently warp/stretch a Posted by u/St_Ginger - 2 votes and 10 comments Hmmm, okay. After owning both, I prefer sil nylon. The 1. 1 oz silnylon or silpoly. For example, the 1. In case you don't know, silpoly and silnylon are both fabrics. I'm using a RSBTR 1. Examples include better zippers, higher denier fabrics, silpoly vs silnylon fabrics (silpoly is superior in the rain, dries out faster and is far more resistant to UV light damage), larger tent size, larger vestibules etc. I’ve also used both in shoulder season with snowfall and the same applies. 6 with Sil/Sil coating (they claim 3000 mm HH). Compared to the Li it’s obviously heavier. Silnylon will be stronger for the weight, but will stretch and hold water when wet. I have no regrets about the bug net. Silpoly: Pros and Cons. Can anyone with some real world experience using these products help me. Also a silnylon rain skirt for many rainy hikes. If you don't catch it a rip will keep going. I try to limit mechanical stress by folding (don't fold it the same way each time) and rolling and avoiding stuffing. 1 Silpoly and 1. I have read to store in a sil nylon bag, which is slippery and less abrasive than DCF. It comes down mostly to silnylon vs silpoly construction. - First, the silpoly should stretch less and absorb less water which is good. Also, with the silpoly RTBTRs offerings kind of confusing as to what the coatings actually are. Mine comes in at 660g with seam sealing. And don’t see what the slippery quality of silpoly has to do with it. 1 for your jacket and pants), but mine allows some flexibility based on the conditions, and the sun umbrella doubles as . I’d say the Montbell Jacket you have actually falls somewhere between the . The silnylon is fine, but I use a polycro footprint (about 50 g). Makes me both impressed but skeptical about the silnylon version. I cannot imagine either getting shredded at all even on granite. High stress tends to grind sand into the interior sides of the slider instead of giving the malleable teeth the opportunity to bend around the grains. It also shakes off water beautifully. I’ve used both and love the fact that Silpoly doesn’t get saggy after being soaked with morning dew. I think you’d be happy a with 20D silpoly tarp. Silnylon is more durable than DCF, which is reported to last 200 nights or so, perhaps more if it is stored correctly. I would think a Dyneema grid could give some of the lighter woven tent fabrics, like 0. 51 dcf. It’s also more packable. You have to go slow. I suspect silnylon is as well. It remains to be seen how durable it will be over the long term, but it seems promising. And I don't consider the added bulk an issue, as my tarp stays on the outside of my pack. there are some improvements, and some negatives based on my initial comparisons. I can really see the value of both. 50 at Ripstop By the Roll. I've got an asym I made from 1. I was originally set on the Silpoly PU4000 but they don't have the color I'm really wanting but it's available in the MTN Silnylon. 74 to . 5oz Cuben fiber. Color is a BIG factor. With tarps, you need a taught pitch. 1 MTN silnylon, so I can’t offer anything on that. Even 15D silnylon floor will last hundreds of nights and anything that will poke a hole in 15D will go right through polycryo. DSM has sat on their laurels making a killing on DCF while the rest of the industry has hustled to catch-up. But given that silpoly has the better UV resistance, there’s no reason to believe that it would fail quicker than silpoly. every place besides paria that sells either 30D silnylon or a shelter made with it advertises a 3000mm resistance. It’s a pain in the butt to dry out compared to silpoly. These recommendations are all for waterproof breathable rainjackets ( vs things like silpoly ponchos) but if you want something that has 3layers is decently lightweight with pitzips that can also be used outside of hiking and has a decently thick face fabric (20d+) I'd say the montbell stormcruiser (280g) or the mountain equipment firefox (330g) would both be great all rounders. 5 x 9 flat tarp and used over 30 nights. This also explains why it is lighter than the AGG jacket. im also a little wary of paria tbh; they advertise their tarp as 30D silnylon with 5000mm hydrostatic resistance, but that doesnt seem to exist. Imo silpoly is a better jacket material as it doesn’t soak up water like silnylon does. 7 ounces, the silpoly tunic option is pretty sweet. Most importantly, it compresses down nicely, to at least half the volume of an equivalent Tyvek sheet. Meanwhile silpoly is less than 1/2 of the price and DCF is a pain to have to fold every time you want to put it away, plus it takes up a lot more room than Dcf tents are very light. 1 silpoly. Interested to hear what you find out or go with! I've made some tarps too, and next on the project list are bivies. 5x9 by borah. The current silpoly we carry has a slightly lower waterproof rating than the silnylon, but other than that, the silpoly seems to be pulling ahead. I am planning to start sewing with slippery 1. Silny is just a bad option for wet and humid climates. purchased from Ripstop by the Roll: 0. Other than the fabrics you mentioned, DCF, SilPoly, SilNylon, I'm not sure what else you could use. Le poids serait quasiment identique, avec seulement 30grammes en plus pour le 40D silpoly. Jul 9, 2018 路 Silnylon is stronger than silpoly when new, however UV rays degrade silnylon quickly. I’ve been using the LightHeart gear silpoly rain jacket for a little over a month now and so far it fits my needs pretty well. , a 30d silnylon from a NatureHike tent. Some pieces of gear are worth it investing the money in. 0oz Cuben fiber is listed at 3. I'd go for silpoly because it will be very waterproof. ($120 vs $150). They pack smaller too. I found hearsay on backpackinglight that silnylon can vary from 1200mm to 3500mm just based on process, without too much change in weight. I'd only use the 7D nylon for a summer "just in case" tarp, but in that context it's the best and I wouldn't use DCF in its place anymore (I have made DCF and 7D summer tarps). I've only brought mine (1. I have tested Asian fabrics which are nylon 6. Part of this is done already by keeping tension on the corners of the floor, but think the poly would also help to prevent slipping and bunching up. The good news is, most peoples tents aren't up for too long in the sun when they're hiking. a sun umbrella! But yeah, at 4. This sub-Reddit is ultralight so people here regularly drop $700 on tents spun from spider webs :-) and tend to prefer trekking pole tents, so you might get more input at r/campinggear. . I've used a HG quest, which is 20D silpoly, for years and just got a silpoly thunderfly that I've used on one trip now. But a light colored silpoly vs a darker nylon--well, the nylon will fare better. I do carry both DCF patch/tape and silnylon patch in my repair kit. 1 Intruder silnylon rigged exactly like the silpoly Monster and the Monster definitely packs smaller and feels lighter. Silpoly is a waterproof fabric made from polyester, while silnylon is a lightweight nylon material with a silicone coating that adds water resistance to the fabric. This subreddit values interesting discussion, not "quick pic" posts. I believe that both are polyester, which give significantly less strech than silnylon, and better UV resistance. If silnylon was just as good, I would use that. The only real difference I can tell is that xenon lists a hydrostatic head of 1000' while silpoly, I believe, is 1500. Pitches nice and tight and packs small. My short review on the LHG is that the hood design is super duper comfy on my head and I often find hoods uncomfortable and restricting, but the inner storm flap always gets caught on the zipper, and that's super annoying. Other possible cons (objective) We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Even economics are against it. 43 votes, 18 comments. 0lbf and they seemed like they were really trying to jam that nail through fairly hard in the last one, and the SilNylon is listed as having much stronger tear strength in the specs sheet than all the Cuben fibers. A couple of disadvantages of DCF that you haven't mentioned. That first link reads like someone trying to justify the materials they use moreso than provide complete information. 75 and 1. Jun 8, 2023 路 Like Dyneema, UltraTNT is what is known as a composite fabric. silpoly, pros and cons question. My old silny tent would absorb water, and it took 3x as long to dry in the sun and wind than my brothers silpoly. Have hiked extensively with cuben and silnylon tarps. The three man materials I am considering are 1. if someone actually managed to make an even more waterproof 30D silnylon, would they Oct 15, 2023 路 The choice between Silnylon and Silpoly will depend on your specific requirements, whether you prioritize minimal sagging or want additional tear resistance. When given a choice between 1. either way, it shoud be able to handle it, but check it every few days of use for abrasion or wear, just to be safe! 1. you might think these tent fabrics would react the same way, but the end result is always a more slackened pitch in wet/cold conditions vs warm and dry. I'm thinking about making a tarp partly with the intention of using it for shade on group trips. Silpoly will keep you drier and thus warmer. e. Warbonnet's silpoly holds up fine in the winter and is the superior option. The silnylon tents cost more, weigh less and have a higher tear strength than silpoly. FWIW, Simply Light makes a nice groundcloth in 1. Some show normal variation; others are actually inferior. Silpoly. Silpoly is awesome and is the better fabric choice in a lot of applications, but silnylon is significantly stronger than silpoly at a given weight, and most silnylons have much better ripstop properties than silpoly. Better hydrostatic head ratings, better warranty (lifetime on Big Agnes, Marmot, Sierra Designs, MSR etc), lighter, better rainfly materials (silpoly vs silnylon), much better carbon fiber or aluninum DAC poles, better guylines, usually full coverage rain fly (vs partial on most Coleman tents), much better ventilation with the mesh body vs most . Also, I'm pretty sure its 30d silnylon, just like the 30d silnylon floor of my shelter, which is plenty durable. Check out the 3F UL gear silnylon poncho tarp for a nice light one--it used to be $20 which was a bargain but I think the price has gone up a bit. I haven't personally made anything with the silpoly yet, but all the feedback I've gotten on the silpoly has been very positive. . More typically used as basic rain wear. I have the Yama, and I have the 5. 6oz and 1. While silnylon and silpoly are traditional woven fabrics coated in liquid silicone, UltraTNT and Dyneema are laminated. Sil nylon stretches ( a bit ) , sags ( a bit ) , and will absorb a tiny TINY bit of water. Especially since floors are commonly the limiting factor for the entire shelter - you're potentially paying $50 to halve the lifespan of your expensive DCF shelter for a mere 1oz savings. Bonding Silpoly / Silnylon tarp If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. And, I think that Silnylon is better for the job I want it to do. 0 in terms or warmth. I do distain the slipperyness of silnylon, but spending an extra $50 to get a floor with a far shorter lifespan is just not an efficient way to save 1 oz. Black and very dark blue are the best for both silpoly and silnylon. Instead of an even handed approach, it's really negative on materials they don't use (to the point of giving incorrect info and trying to associate it as low end), but then for materials they do use they don't even mention the most basic negatives (like the sag of nylon). If the poly turns out to be less abrasion resistant for whatever reason; then it’s back to silnylon. Both basically the same weight fabric so it will be interesting to see how they stack up to each other. "As you may have guessed from their names, silpoly is made from silicone-coated polyester while silnylon is made from silicone coated nylon Also, I'm pretty sure its 30d silnylon, just like the 30d silnylon floor of my shelter, which is plenty durable. Dec 2, 2022 路 Silpoly vs Silnylon for Tarps & Tents – Pros & Cons (Overview) Hiking , Backpacking , Camping / By Mikkel Skødt Damsgaard / December 2, 2022 When it comes to choosing materials for tarps and tents, different materials have distinct advantages and disadvantages, and deciding which trade-offs to make is necessary for selecting the “right” one. What machine would be best for this, e. Its silpoly, and I feel like it sagged less, absorbed less water, and misted WAY less than the silnylon Borah. 93 OSY Membrane silpoly. Overall my kit weighs more than yours (14. From what I understand Silpoly is less effected by UV light (the sun) and is almost 3 times as waterproof as Silnylon. I found this video from Zpacks, they poke a nail through 1. For reference, I tested tie outs in silnylon/silpoly vs membrane silpoly. Would probably be fine as a groundsheet, but just want to mention that . It's easy to repair with T-Tape though. It's not as touch as poly. 6 oz version) out on one 4-day hike, but it performs well. Silnylon fabric is durable but the waterproofing does not last forever. I have a UGQ 10x12 Winter Dream in 1. But that paticular one has caused enough warranty claims that most early adopters have stopped using it. Mar 31, 2016 路 Silpoly is a good bit lighter than the older versions of silnylon and the cheap china stuff (not so much the newer high tech stuff). 6, have a pressure rating several times that of the stock American silnylon, and are slightly lighter than stock silnylon. PS The price difference is also from different fabrics and poles so make sure you understand the pros and cons of silpoly vs silnylon. Also, a lot hinges on your use case. Like others have said, I'd go with silpoly first (and maybe last!). Weights are very similar between the two. Polyester as a fabric does no absorb water, but at the same denier it is not as strong or abrasion resistant as Nylon. Normally sil-poly is heavier than Sil-nylon, but the latter will stretch over time, which means in a hammock tarp it’ll end up possibly against your hammock or bug net in the morning. While this is relatively new to the tent market, it picks up where silnylon left off and adds some property improvements. I opted for silpoly over silnylon because silnylon is more prone to sagging when wet. Oct 19, 2024 路 Discover the pros and cons of silnylon, silpoly, and DCF tent materials. 1 oz silpoly and a hex tarp I made from membrane silpoly. Don't take it through bushes but otherwise you'll be sorted. However, I own a Trekkertent Stealth 1 in the thicker (70d iirc) silnylon, as well as a "silpoly" tarp from trekkertent. As far as sewing I haven't really noticed any difference Would it be correct to say that 40d silnylon is better for dry, sandy environments because it has a higher abrasion resistance, but 20d silpoly is better for wet climates because it doesn't absorb water and doesn't sag in the rain? It's so so so much better at shedding water than silnylon in my experience -- you don't get any of the misting at all. It's lighter and packs down very well. It's bulkier, and harder to pack. However, with the right technique, it can pack quite small. I wouldn't worry about it for normal use, but in repeated high wind conditions where the fabric was stress cycled, I'd prefer a silnylon long-term. Is UV resistance maybe the biggest shortcoming of silnylon? Aug 15, 2021 路 Hi all, After reading your discussions about polyester vs nylon (thank you for those), I’m still planning on using silnylon for my next tent and was pretty settled on RBTR’s 1. They both work fine, but RSBTR recommends using silicone to glue on the reinforcement patches instead of sewing them on the membrane. Oct 10, 2016 路 Both SilPoly and SilNylon have a lot of variations. 61/yd. SilNylon stretches and wets out or soaks in some water when it rains which requires the use of some shock cord guy lines to keep the tarp taught. I would have to reccomend a sil-nylon poncho as the ultimate, ultralight raingear. This is not to say SilNylon isnt waterproof or a good material. 6 oz silpoly spec sheet says it's silicone coated on both sides, but the page selling it says it's silicone/PU. Basic physics indicates most things contract (shrink) as temperatures are lowered, and expand as temps increase. Besides, DCF is trivially patched. I like the Yama. I will probably end up getting the regular MLD bug bivy. In addition to excellent waterproof/windproof characteristics, SilPoly offers lower water absorption and increased UV resistance compared to SilNylon. Jul 2, 2020 路 Hey guys, would like to make a rain cover, meat bag (large dry bag to drop all of the breathable meat bags into for transport) and also some small pull-out bags/dry bags for gear in the pack. Silpoly has much less stretch than silnylon. Mar 29, 2006 路 Je vais donc partir sur du 40D mais j'hésite entre le silnylon 40D et le silpoly 40D. My perspective as the owner of LightHeart Gear - we went back to silnylon after a round of silpoly tents . 1 Silpoly PU400. DCF does not like that! I started to see tiny holes in mine after a year. I don’t think silpoly will be any different. Taffeta only goes down to 2. 1 Silnylon PU coated, 1. X-mids are the other popular option obvs. Note, just a windshirt is fine for lighter rain I wear poncho + windshirt and it works great! What is the cost difference of a 7x9 silpoly/silnylon vs a 7x9 DCF tarp, like $200? For me, that’s worth it. It’s stout, but probably a lot heavier than you want for a fly. I'm not sure. " This is pretty debatable and I don't think anyone has ever properly tested it. Tenacious tape makes a silnylon patch. The design allows for maximum mechanical ventilation, and you never have to worry about ”wetting out” or waterproof coatings failing. , Pfaff IDT, pinfeed (a la brother or baby lock), industrial needle feed, other? I realize that there are tricks and things that can be done to help keep the feeding even, but I am looking for the best tool, out of the box, to use without utilizing I’m hesitant to get a SilPoly rain jacket, my tarp is SilPoly and hasn’t been the most durable thing and I often hike off trail including bushwhacks. I think of pyramids as foul-weather shelters, so this is a big deal to me here. The silpoly did not hold up as well, it leaked (misted) way more than the nylon, and the real amount of 'sag' was rather minimal. But for the true ultralight purists, silnylon still reigns supreme, with 10-denier options that are lighter than any silpoly on the market. Water leaks through silnylon (orange) and polyester (silver) tubes made of tent fabric. Hey there, I am looking for a lightweight tarp, but my budget is only around 100-150 Dollars. Both fabrics are equally waterproof, it’s just that silpoly absorbs much less water. "a silnylon tent will have better wind resistance and durability compared to a silpoly tent of similar denier, simply based on the properties of the fabric. For a slight weight penalty you end up with almost zero stretch, similar water shedding and better packability with SilPoly for shelters and the same would apply to rain gear. The floor material was a deliberate design choice as sil-nylon is more puncture and abrasion resistant than DCF. The floor is silnylon not silpoly which is probably for Membrane silpoly does not have that same gridwork. /r/hammockcamping is a subreddit devoted to the **discussion** of hammock camping. 5 oz vs $90 on the 1p, or 2. So, while it is lighter (because it does not have that gridwork of heavier thread), it does not have the tear strength of regular silnylon and is also not as durable. Many high end backpacking tents use SilNylon (Big Agnes Tiger Wall as an example) for UV resistance and lower weight vs polyester and of course Nylon hiking pants are awesome vs cotton. I own the older silnylon beta light, and recently received the new silpoly version. Just tighten up the tent before you go to sleep for the night. Much easier to work with along with the stretch and UV advantages. They say: Fix tears and rips in lightweight fabrics with Tenacious Tape Silnylon Patches. inpgadnyzoibpqpcpnttivawubkgfygoybeiidxqxujzwtnjbllw